New article!

Catching Mind Wandering With Pupillometry: Conceptual and Methodological Challenges

Is pupillometry a valid biomarker of MW?

Hello there!

A new article is out! link

In this paper we wonder whether, and if so why, measuring pupil size may give us insights about elusive internal processes and their locus: Mind-Wandering.

Much props to Claudia and Manila for this, and thanks for involving me: it has been an intriguing subject!

The abstract reads:

Mind-wandering (MW) refers to the shift of attention away from an ongoing task and/or external environment towards mental contents (e.g., memories, prospective thoughts) unrelated to the task. Physiological measures (e.g., pupil size, EEG, and fMRI) have often been acquired as objective markers for MW states, which has greatly helped their study as well as triangulation with other measures. Pupillometry in particular has been used as a covert biomarker of MW because it is reliably modulated by several distinct processes spanning arousal, emotion, and attention, and it signals attentional lapses. Yet, coupling MW and the measurement of pupil size has led to seemingly contrasting results. We argue that, common to the studies reviewed here, one reason is resolving to the measurement of tonic pupil size, which reflects low-frequency, slow changes in one’s physiological state, and thus implicitly assumes that MW is a static, long-lasting process. We then additionally focus on three major axes of variability in the reviewed studies: (i) the definition and measurement of MW; (ii) the impact of contextual aspects, such as task demands and individual arousal levels; (iii) the identification and tracking of MW in combination with pupillary measures. We provide an overview of these differences and put forward recommendations for using physiological measures—including, but not limited to, pupil size—in MW research effectively. In conclusion, pupillometry can be a very informative tool for MW research, provided that it is used with the due methodological caution.

Link to the paper: https://wires.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/journal/19395086

Elvio Blini
Elvio Blini
Assistant Professor of Psychobiology and Physiological Psychology

Italian cognitive (neuro)scientist. Taciturn.